The newest member of the Judicial Qualifications Commission, longtime investigator Richard Hyde, is the target of harsh criticism by panel chairman Lester Tate and JQC director Mark Dehler, both Democrats.
Before being named a JQC member recently by Gov. Nathan Deal recently, Hyde was the panel’s chief investigator. His probes led to dozens of corrupt or incompetent judges being removed in recent years, so he naturally made enemies among the friends of those ousted judges.
Tate unleashed a broadside against Hyde this week, telling the The Fulton Daily Report that “there were repeated incidents” in which he made inquiries “when our executive director had no idea where he was going or what he was doing.” Tate also claims his nemesis has been chided about that practice “repeatedly over the years” and that some commissioners worried that Hyde retained possession of files, documents and recordings that he compiled during ethics investigations of judges. “The commissioners don’t even know what he has, and to access it,” Tate claims.
Hyde rejects the charges, saying Tate and Dehler were conspiring to fire him as JQC investigator. InsiderAdvantage is told that the governor, tiring of the reign of Tate & Co., protected Hyde by naming him to the commission—and then hoping that Tate could then be ousted.
Aside from this fight, Tate and others are resisting a proposed constitutional amendment to abolish the JQC and then allowing the General Assembly to recreate it. The legislation would strip the State Bar of Georgia of the power to appoint three of the JQC’s seven members.
The sponsor is House Judiciary Committee Chairman Wendell Willard, R-Sandy Springs. Willard dropped the bill, he says, because of growing concerns that the JQC under Tate has become a “star chamber.”
Tate came under criticism last summer, for example, for his handling of now ex-Judge Cynthia Becker of DeKalb County. Prominent King & Spalding partner Ben Easterlin IV told the Daily Report that the ethics charges and a separate grand jury investigation regarding statements made to some JQC members by Becker undermined a long-held practice of inviting judges to speak privately and candidly about complaints or allegations of possible misconduct.
“The JQC is not a star chamber,” he told reporter Robin McDonald. “And it’s not intended … for everybody who comes before it to be subject to an inquisition. It’s designed to help educate a judge. It’s designed to help guide judges when they have questions, to guide judges when they need input about things they don’t realize that are not quite right, and to discipline judges when something really bad goes on. It requires judgment and not prosecutorial zeal because [the JQC] is not a prosecutorial entity.”
Easterlin blasted Tate for conducting “an inquisition” against Becker, and criticism by Hyde and others have been mounting against the JQC chairman ever since.



